What Is Needed To Prove Wrongful Death?

What Is Needed To Prove Wrongful Death?

The loss of a loved one is an emotionally devastating experience. It becomes even more heartrending when the death was preventable and occurred due to the negligence or misconduct of another party. In these instances, a wrongful death lawsuit is necessary to seek justice and compensation.

While no amount of money can make up for losing a loved one, holding the responsible parties accountable may provide solace and financial support during this challenging time.

However, proving wrongful death involves a convoluted legal process.

An experienced wrongful death attorney can explain what you need to establish wrongful death and the role they play in navigating the challenging process.

Schedule a Free Initial Consultation Today!

Understanding Wrongful Death

Following a tragedy, understanding what constitutes a wrongful death forms the basis of a legal claim. A wrongful death case is a civil action that family members or the deceased's estate can bring against the party whose negligent or intentional act caused the death of their loved one.

Wrongful death is a broad and complicated term that accommodates various scenarios. It can occur in many circumstances, from automobile accidents to violent, reckless acts. Each represents a unique situation and presents its own legal challenges. Remember that every case is unique, and the specifics of an incident play a significant role in the outcome of a wrongful death claim.

A web of laws and regulations entangle wrongful death claims that vary depending on your state and situation. The emotional and legal complications can prove difficult for those unfamiliar with the process, emphasizing the importance of legal counsel guiding you through these legal actions.

Wrongful Death Claim Vs. Survival Actions

What Is Needed To Prove Wrongful Death

While the two terms are often used interchangeably, a wrongful death claim and survival action represent two distinct legal procedures. A wrongful death claim compensates survivors for their loss.

At the same time, a survival action compensates for damages the deceased could have recovered had they survived.

Wrongful death claims generally account for damages like loss of income, medical and funeral expenses, pain and suffering, loss of companionship, and more. On the other hand, survival actions primarily cover damages the deceased incurred while living, such as pain and suffering, medical costs, and more.

In some states, wrongful death and survival actions may be sought, while others may only allow one of these claims. Your attorney can clarify the differences and explain which type of claim applies to your situation.

Who Can File a Wrongful Death Lawsuit?

Typically, the deceased's immediate family members always have the right to file a wrongful death claim. Still, depending on the laws of the state, others outside immediate family members may file a claim.

The list of claimants may include:

  • Spouse
  • Life partners
  • Children
  • Parents
  • Siblings
  • Grandparents
  • Distant family members
  • Financial dependents

An attorney will know who has the legal right to file a claim under the specific laws of your area.

Challenges in a Wrongful Death Lawsuit

Filing a wrongful death lawsuit presents many challenges. Numerous, complex legal issues can arise. From understanding the state's laws and collecting evidence to quantifying the damages and filing paperwork on time, a misstep could have irrevocable consequences. Additionally, dealing with insurance companies and adhering to convoluted legal procedures is strenuous, particularly during a time of grief.

Experienced attorneys can navigate these challenges, ensuring your case receives the attention it deserves. They will examine the facts of your case, make sure you understand the laws, and apply their legal experience to build a strong claim. They will also represent you in court or during settlement negotiations and demystify challenging legal concepts.

Understanding Comparative and Contributory Negligence Concepts

Comparative and contributory negligence are two legal concepts that can play a role in determining fault after a wrongful death. Comparative negligence considers the deceased's potential role in their own accident, possibly reducing the final compensation. Contributory negligence, a more stringent concept, potentially bars any recovery if the deceased was responsible for their own demise.

Understanding how these legal concepts interact with your wrongful death case is important. An experienced attorney can provide clarity on how they apply to your specific situation and explain what their implications might be.

Filing a Wrongful Death Claim Within Time Limitations

Every state has a statute of limitations, a time limit within which you must file a wrongful death claim. The clock usually starts ticking from the date of death. You may lose your right to file a lawsuit if your claim is not filed within this period. Understanding this deadline and ensuring timely filing underlines the importance of seeking legal advice immediately.

The time limit varies from state to state, and the specifics of your case can also influence the deadline. It is important to clarify this limitation with your lawyer, as missing the deadline may be fatal to the success of your claim.

Negotiating With Insurance Companies

Insurance companies are a significant hurdle in wrongful death cases. While their job is to provide coverage and compensation to the defendant or, in some cases, to the deceased's family, they're also businesses focused on minimizing their payout. Their involvement comes in various forms.

Insurance companies often attempt to settle quickly and outside of court for a fraction of what your claim is worth. In addition, insurance companies tend to delay settlements or deny claims, while the process to dispute this is complicated and lengthy. Your attorney can navigate the intricacies of this process and represent you during settlement negotiations or in court.

Understanding the legal framework of a wrongful death claim is necessary for navigating your legal journey. Your attorney must prove four main elements in a wrongful death lawsuit. Together, these elements form the foundation of your claim, and your lawyer will meticulously work to establish each of them.

Duty of Care

The first step in a wrongful death claim is establishing that the defendant had a duty of care towards the deceased. Your lawyer will work diligently to illustrate how the accused individual had a legal obligation to ensure the safety of your loved one.

Breach of Duty

Once a duty of care is established, your lawyer will then have to prove that the defendant breached this duty, meaning they failed to act in a reasonable manner that any other person in the same situation would have.


Merely establishing a breach of duty is not sufficient. Your lawyer will further need to prove causation—that is, the breach of duty directly caused the death of your loved one.


Lastly, it's necessary to demonstrate that the death of a loved one resulted in measurable damages. These can include medical and funeral expenses, loss of income, and emotional suffering.

Remember, proving these elements is complicated and time-consuming, requiring a vast understanding of legal rules and regulations. An experienced wrongful death lawyer becomes indispensable because they will meticulously analyze the facts, gather and evaluate evidence, and use their deep understanding of the law to build a strong case.

The Role of an Experienced Wrongful Death Attorney

Your attorney will be responsible for building a robust case. They will initiate an independent investigation to collect evidence, a key component in establishing a duty of care, breach of duty, causation, and damages.

Collecting evidence can involve a multitude of tasks, including 

  • Gathering medical records
  • Obtaining police reports
  • Interviewing witnesses and expert witnesses
  • Reconstructing accident scenes

Next, they will rigorously assess the evidence, using their breadth of legal knowledge to establish a link between the defendant's actions and the wrongful death. This evidence evaluation stage involves not only proving that the defendant was negligent but also that this negligence directly resulted in the loss of your loved one.

In addition, your wrongful death attorney will quantify damages. This ability is a detailed process because damages in a wrongful death claim include not only financial losses such as medical expenses and funeral costs but also encompass non-economic damages like the loss of companionship and emotional distress.

Lastly, the attorney is pivotal in negotiating settlements or representing you in court. They will strategically use the evidence available to argue your case with the opposing counsel during negotiations or before a judge in court.

Pain and Suffering in Wrongful Death Cases

In the aftermath of a wrongful death, the pain and suffering experienced by the loved ones left behind is immeasurable. It's a deep emotional trauma that is a significant component of a wrongful death claim. This aspect of the claim, often referred to as non-economic damages, is hard to quantify but nonetheless important.

Loss of Companionship

Also known as loss of consortium, loss of companionship is a form of non-economic damages. It reflects the deprivation of the love, care, and companionship the deceased would have provided. Your attorney will work closely with you to understand the depth of your relationship with the deceased and articulate this loss effectively.

Emotional Distress

Another non-economic damage that you can claim is emotional distress. Dealing with the sudden and tragic loss of a loved one can lead to severe emotional aftershocks. It's damages that are not easily quantifiable. Still, an experienced attorney can translate this emotional trauma into a legal claim.

Punitive Damages

Your attorney can also pursue these damages in a wrongful death case. These types of damages don't compensate the family for their loss but instead punish the defendant for their egregious conduct and deter similar behavior in the future. Your attorney will advise you on the likelihood of seeking punitive damages based on the specifics of your case.

Establishing the value of these damages is complicated and requires the knowledge of a seasoned attorney who can argue effectively for just and fair compensation for your loss. A lawyer will understand how these damages could apply to your case.

Losing a loved one is a trying time, and navigating a wrongful death claim amidst this emotional turmoil amplifies the challenges. Ensuring justice while also dealing with the complexity of such a lawsuit underlines the importance of obtaining competent legal guidance.

Understanding and applying intricate laws, gathering and evaluating evidence, negotiating with insurance companies, and defending your case in court, all while grieving, is daunting. An experienced wrongful death attorney lifts this burden, dedicating their knowledge and experience to fight for justice on your behalf.

Your attorney will ensure that your claim meets all legal requirements, deadlines are adhered to, and all available avenues of compensation are explored. They will be a steadfast ally, advising you through each step of the process, answering your questions, and assuaging your concerns.

A wrongful death lawsuit is not just about monetary compensation but about seeking justice for your loved one and holding the responsible parties accountable. With an experienced attorney by your side, you can focus on healing and remembrance while they focus on delivering justice.

Seek individual legal advice to understand how an attorney can guide you through your unique situation. Remember, a personal consultation with an attorney will provide guidance tailored to your specific circumstances.

An Experienced Attorney Is Needed if a Wrongful Death Has Happened

James Holliday. Attorney for Wrongful Death in Florida
James Holliday, Wrongful Death Lawyer in Florida

The path to justice after the wrongful death of a loved one is fraught with emotional and legal complexities. At such a challenging time, understanding the intricacies of a wrongful death claim, from its fundamental elements to the pivotal role of an experienced attorney, will serve you in this time of need.

Remember, establishing a duty of care, proving a breach of duty, demonstrating causation, and quantifying damages form the bedrock of your claim.

An attorney's role extends far beyond mere representation. From collecting evidence to establishing legal elements, quantifying your emotional trauma and loss, and representing you during settlement negotiations or in court, an experienced wrongful death attorney works to right the wrongs.

In this challenging journey, an experienced personal injury attorney is not just an advisor but a pillar of support, a voice for your loved one, and an advocate for justice.

James Wayne Holliday Author Image

James Wayne Holliday

James Wayne Holliday has been practicing law since 1995. He has been named as a “Best Attorney” Lifetime Charter Member in Florida, an honor awarded to less than one percent of the nation’s lawyers.

Mr. Holliday has earned a reputation as a relentless trial lawyer because of his outstanding work ethic and thorough preparation of his cases for trial.

Author's Bio


Book a Free Consultation